Blog Layout

Tax Alert - ATO appeals to High Court in the Bendel Case decision

Lowe Lippmann Chartered Accountants

ATO appeals to High Court in the Bendel Case decision


The Australian Taxation Office (ATO) has now applied to the High Court for special leave to appeal the Full Federal Court’s decision in FCT v Bendel [2025] FCAFC 15.

 

Last month, we released a Tax Alert (see here) after the Federal Court delivered their unanimous decision that an unpaid present entitlement (or UPE) owed by a discretionary trust to a corporate beneficiary is not a “loan” for Division 7A purposes.

 

The ATO has also issued an Interim Decision Impact Statement (DIS) in response to the Full Federal Court decision. A DIS provides information for taxpayers and advisers, and includes: details of the case, a brief summary of facts, issues decided by the court or tribunal, and relevant legislation and case law.


What is the ATO’s current view?


The ATO view can be summarised as follows:

  • Will continue to administer the tax rules in their current form (ie. treating UPEs as loans for Division 7A purposes) until the outcome of the appeal process is known.
  • Will hold off processing amendments, private rulings and objections relating to this issue until the appeal process is finalised.
  • Regardless of the new interpretation by the Full Federal Court, the reimbursement agreement rules in section 100A will continue to be considered, and this decision does not change the potential for exposure to Subdivision EA (ie. a trust makes a UPE to corporate beneficiary, and then the trust makes a payment or loan, to the shareholders or associates of the corporate beneficiary).

What can we do now?


Unfortunately, the way forward in the short term is unclear until we see how the appeal process moves to, and through, the High Court.


Again, there is an element of having to “wait and see” what happens next. We will continue to keep you updated on all future developments.



Please do not hesitate to contact your Lowe Lippmann Relationship Partner if you wish to discuss any of these matters further.

Liability limited by a scheme approved under Professional Standards Legislation


March 27, 2025
Bill passed for Instant Asset Write-Off of $20,000 for 2024-25 There was no mention of the extension of the instant asset write-off ( IAWO ) within the Federal Budget delivered last Tuesday night, leaving many small business taxpayers frustrated and uncertain. However, the Treasury Laws Amendment (Tax Incentives and Integrity) Bill 2025 has now been passed through the Parliament, and it included the extension of the IAWO threshold of $20,000 for assets first used or installed ready for use between 1 July 2024 and 30 June 2025. After the Bill has now been passed by both the House of Representatives and the Senate, it now simply waits to receive Royal assent.
March 25, 2025
SUMMARY AND FULL COMMENTARY UPDATES 
March 17, 2025
External audit is often considered to be ‘just a compliance exercise’, however while these financial statements audits are often required to meet legal obligations, they can provide significant value beyond ticking a regulatory box. An important question is to consider why you are having an audit: Is it required by legislation / constituting documents? Have your suppliers / customers / funders requested one? Board / Management has chosen to have an audit for good governance practices. The reason for your audit can shape what you need from your auditor. Look for an auditor with industry experience and if you are a not-for-profit or small business entity then experience in that sector is critical. An external auditor should not only understand your organisation’s unique challenges but also bring insights in relation to financial risks in your industry and best practice improvements. Remember an external auditor needs to be independent so be careful about using someone with a particular relationship with the entity even if they do offer to do the work for a cheap price. An external doesn’t just identify material errors; they offer practical advice for improving financial management and help foster a culture of transparency and accountability. An effective audit can strengthen internal operations and bolster the confidence of donors, investors, and regulators in your organisation’s financial health. If you don’t need a financial statement audit, then consider using an auditor to perform work on specific areas to provide detailed recommendations and provide an opinion on accuracy over key systems. This work is equivalent to an internal audit project where the auditor does not need to be independent and can agree the scope with management, this could cover financial and non-financial areas such as payroll, purchasing system, compliance with specific standards (e.g. child safety, health and safety, privacy).
More Posts
Share by: